Some people believe occult practice can make unlikely things happen or even change reality. Is that a literal change in probability, or is there another way to understand it?
Can magic actually change probability, or does it work another way?
Answers
There is a difference between feeling that a ritual helped and showing that it changed probability. Unlikely events happen without magic too, and the striking hits are easier to remember than all the misses.
For a literal claim, you would need a clear prediction made in advance, a way to count failures as well as successes, and repeated tests against a suitable comparison. Without that, a meaningful coincidence is still a coincidence, at least as far as the evidence can tell us.
Reply to this answer
You can also think of ritual as a way to focus attention and shape behavior. If it makes someone more confident or more likely to notice an opportunity, their chances might change through ordinary actions rather than a supernatural effect.
Reply to this answer
For someone with an occult worldview, changing probability may be a literal belief rather than a metaphor for motivation. That is a different claim from saying every unlikely result proves a spell worked, though. The belief and the evidence for a particular result are separate questions.
Reply to this answer
I'd be careful with the word impossible. Something with a very small chance can still happen, but that does not make it impossible. If you want to explore the idea, keeping track of predictions before the outcome might make the distinction clearer.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
6v+zarmqeli:
That distinction helps. A result can feel significant without proving what caused it.