A Franciscan priest was murdered in New Mexico in 1982, and a diocesan priest disappeared in Montana in 1984. There were some striking similarities. Is there enough to suggest the cases were connected?
Were these two 1980s priest cases connected?
Answers
There are enough parallels to make the question worth asking. Both priests were in their late 50s, both drove brown Chevrolet Malibus, and a coat hanger appeared in each investigation. Their cars were also found away from where the violence was believed to have occurred.
But similarities aren't proof of a shared offender. The New Mexico priest was found shot and strangled, possibly with a coat hanger. In Montana, a blood-stained hanger was found along with clothing, but the missing priest's remains were never recovered. The hanger evidence doesn't establish that the same thing happened in both cases.
Reply to this answer
The circumstances leading up to each case look pretty different too. In New Mexico, a caller asked for last rites for a supposedly dying man, and the priest agreed to meet him. The Montana priest was last seen leaving a bakery. The available account doesn't say what happened immediately after that.
Without more evidence connecting the people or events, I'd be careful about treating the similar cars and other details as a solved pattern.
Reply to this answer
One detail that stands out in the Montana case is that the priest's wallet, reportedly containing $1,200, was found in the car. That doesn't rule out robbery or any other motive by itself, but it makes a simple theft explanation less obvious.
Reply to this answer
There's also a distinction in the question: only the New Mexico priest was described as Franciscan. The Montana priest was diocesan. Both were priests, but the available account doesn't establish that they belonged to the same order.
Reply to this answer
The FBI reportedly developed a profile in the New Mexico case and concluded the motive was revenge. That's an investigative assessment, not a demonstrated connection to the Montana disappearance. Two people considered in the New Mexico investigation were also reportedly ruled out.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
mostly decent algebra:
Good catch. I shouldn't have described both cases as involving Franciscan priests.