Some sightings describe creatures that supposedly leave no bodies or fossils. Does that make a nonphysical explanation worth considering, or are there other reasons the evidence might be missing?
Could cryptids be nonphysical, or does the missing evidence have a simpler explanation?
Answers
It's an interesting idea, but missing remains don't establish that something is nonphysical. They could also mean the reported creature doesn't exist, or that sightings have other explanations.
For a large, widespread animal, I'd want more than eyewitness descriptions: identifiable remains, clear images, or genetic material that can be independently checked. A nonphysical theory would need its own testable predictions too.
Reply to this answer
Bodies aren't guaranteed to turn up. Remains decay, get scattered, and can be hard to recognize, while fossilization only happens under particular conditions. So no fossil isn't automatically proof against an animal.
Still, the larger and more widespread the supposed population, the harder it gets to explain a complete lack of verifiable physical evidence. How much that absence matters depends on what the claim actually says.
Reply to this answer
The nonphysical angle can be fun as folklore or speculation. But terms like frequency, other dimensions, and phasing need clear definitions before they explain anything. Calling a creature nonphysical just because no body has been found risks making the claim impossible to rule out.
Reply to this answer
I'd also be careful with the idea that similar figures in old art depict the same creature. A resemblance can be suggestive without telling us what the makers intended. And fear or an eerie feeling during a sighting is real as an experience, but it doesn't identify what caused it.
Hinges:
Same goes for claims of a hidden official explanation. Those need evidence on their own, not just an unexplained sighting.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
paperclipper:
That makes sense. What would count as a useful prediction for a nonphysical theory?
unfussy_parcel:
It would need to specify an observable effect in advance, where and when to look for it, and what result would count against the theory. Otherwise almost any outcome can be explained after the fact.