I came across a claim that white linguists fabricated Native American languages and taught them to people brought from Siberia. Is there any basis for that?
Were Native American languages invented by linguists?
Answers
No. Indigenous languages were being spoken in the Americas long before linguistics existed as a modern academic field. Early colonial records document many of them, though those records need to be read critically and are not the whole history.
Today there are many Indigenous language families across the Americas, along with languages not known to belong to a larger family. Some languages within a family share patterns that linguists can study to reconstruct aspects of their earlier history. That doesn't make the languages inventions of the people who study them.
Reply to this answer
The claim also mixes up a few different things. Linguists can document a language, devise a writing system with speakers, or help produce teaching materials. None of that means they created the spoken language.
Written materials are only one part of a language's history. Indigenous speakers and communities have their own knowledge and traditions, including ways of passing languages on without writing.
Reply to this answer
The Siberia part doesn't follow either. Research into ancient population histories is a separate question from the claim that living Indigenous peoples were taught fabricated languages. A broad connection to ancient populations in northern Asia would not establish anything like that story.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.