I've seen this claim framed around Israel's influence on US policy and its effect on world peace. Is that comparison useful, and what would you look at to evaluate it?
Is Israel really a bigger threat to the US than Russia, China, North Korea and Iran combined?
Answers
It depends what you mean by threat. Military attack, cyber operations, economic coercion and influence over US policy are different things. Saying one country is a bigger threat than four others combined needs a measure that puts those risks on the same scale, and the claim doesn't provide one.
Reply to this answer
I'd separate criticism of Israeli government policy from the idea that Americans are simply brainwashed. US officials make their own choices, and domestic political groups can advocate for policies for many reasons. To assess influence, look at specific decisions, who advocated for them and what evidence links that advocacy to the outcome.
Reply to this answer
An ally can still create risks for the US. Support for another government's actions could involve military commitments, diplomatic costs or a wider conflict. That's worth debating on its own terms, without assuming it automatically outweighs every risk posed by other states.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Torqavo-9m:
The comparison also changes depending on whether you're talking about danger to Americans, US interests abroad or international stability. Those aren't quite the same question.