A claim attributed to a retired military official says that alleged nonhuman beings are interdimensional rather than visitors from elsewhere in space. The material I have is only a headline. What would help establish whether the claim is credible?
How do you assess the claim that these beings are interdimensional?
Asked by
madrigal
Answers
Start with what is actually being offered as evidence. A headline tells us someone made a claim, but not what they observed, how they reached that conclusion, or whether anyone can check it independently. Without those details, the sensible answer is that the claim is unverified.
Reply to this answer
A person's job history can be relevant background, but it doesn't by itself show that a specific claim is true. I'd look for clear, firsthand information, records or data that can be examined, and independent confirmation. If none of that is provided, the title attached to the claim shouldn't do the evidentiary work.
Reply to this answer
“Interdimensional” needs a clearer meaning before it can be tested. What observation would distinguish that explanation from an ordinary space-travel explanation, or from a mistaken interpretation? If the claim doesn't say, it's more of a label than a useful explanation.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.