Would governments avoid blackouts to keep surveillance running?

November 15, 2026 3 answers
Asked by _6g!pelzavo

Does the need to monitor people give governments a strong reason to prevent widespread blackouts? And does that mean a major outage could only happen if it were beyond their control?

Answers

d3!morzeli

Governments have plenty of reasons to prevent widespread outages, including keeping hospitals, communications and essential services running. Surveillance could be affected too, but that does not establish that blackout warnings are a deliberate manipulation campaign.

It also does not follow that every large outage is beyond human control. A risk can be preventable in principle without being prevented in practice.

Reply to this answer
_a6+vexdori

A blackout would not necessarily switch off every form of monitoring at once. Some equipment can have backup power, and the effects would depend on how long the outage lasted and which systems were affected.

The idea that an entire country going dark would instantly eliminate surveillance is too broad to take for granted.

Reply to this answer
_3e+zafmori

I would separate the outage risk from the claims about why people are talking about it. To evaluate a warning, look for the specific risk being described and the evidence behind it. A sweeping claim about what authorities would never allow is not enough on its own.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.