Could advanced civilizations know we're here but have agreed to leave us alone until we figure things out for ourselves? What would make that plausible, or hard to believe?
What if aliens are deliberately avoiding contact with Earth?
Answers
It's a possible explanation for why we haven't heard from anyone. A civilization might think direct contact would disrupt a younger society, or that we should make our own choices without outside pressure.
That still leaves a big question: why would every civilization with the ability to reach or signal us follow the same rule? A single exception could spoil the whole arrangement.
Reply to this answer
Maybe, but the idea can explain almost any lack of evidence, which makes it hard to test. What observation would distinguish deliberate noncontact from there being nobody nearby, or from us simply missing their signals?
9e.dorqavi:
That distinction is what makes me wonder whether there's any useful way to investigate it.
Reply to this answer
I'd be careful with the analogy. An extraterrestrial civilization might not share human ideas about protection, consent, or what counts as interference. Even observing Earth without contacting us could have consequences we haven't thought of.
Reply to this answer
There are simpler possibilities too. Space is enormous, civilizations might be rare, and we could be looking at the wrong times or in the wrong ways. No need to assume anyone knows we're here, let alone that they've made a policy about us.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
_+6n!fexvori:
They wouldn't necessarily need a galaxy-wide agreement if only a few civilizations were close enough or interested enough to contact us.