I've seen the theory that World War II was orchestrated to create Israel, with the Rothschild family supposedly financing wars as part of a long-term plan. Is there evidence for that?
Was World War II planned to create Israel?
Answers
There is no credible evidence that World War II was orchestrated to establish Israel. The war resulted from several causes, including Nazi Germany's expansionism and its invasion of Poland in 1939. A later political outcome is not evidence that someone planned the war to produce it.
The Holocaust helped shape international support for a Jewish state, but that is different from saying it was engineered for that purpose.
Reply to this answer
The timeline matters here. Zionism, the movement for a Jewish homeland, existed before World War II. Britain also issued the Balfour Declaration in 1917, supporting a Jewish national home in Palestine. Israel was established in 1948, after the war and after a UN partition plan for Palestine in 1947.
Those developments have their own complicated histories. The war and the Holocaust affected what came afterward, but the movement and the conflict over Palestine did not begin with the war.
Reply to this answer
The Rothschild claim needs specific evidence, not just a broad assertion that a wealthy family funded wars. Wealthy families and banks have financed governments and projects at various times, but that does not establish control over the causes of a world war.
Claims that the Rothschilds secretly direct major world events are also a familiar form of antisemitic conspiracy theory. Ask what documents show a specific decision, who made it, and how the alleged financing actually caused the event.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
!v4+kelzaro~:
So support for a Jewish homeland predates the war, even though the Holocaust changed the political context afterward?
3x+pelviko:
Yes. It is also worth remembering that the partition plan was contested, and the establishment of Israel was accompanied by war and Palestinian displacement.