Does learning from books and folklore make my practice any less valid?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by 6j+plavqori

I learned mostly from books and local folklore, and I use materials I can find nearby. After seeing some popular short videos about witchcraft, I keep worrying that my choices are less effective because they aren't the ones shown online.

How do you deal with that kind of doubt, even when you know popularity isn't a measure of validity?

Answers

5a!vexdori

Popular videos are a pretty narrow window into a huge range of practices. Seeing the same ingredients over and over doesn't establish that they're more effective. It just means they're getting shown a lot.

If a choice makes sense within the folklore or books you're working from, you don't have to replace it just to match what you see online.

Reply to this answer
3h~dornqelo

Maybe separate two questions: what a plant means in a particular tradition, and what it means to you. Those can overlap, but they aren't automatically the same thing. If you're drawing on local folklore, look at the context and compare sources where you can. If you're making a personal substitution, it's fine to call it that rather than treating it as a universal rule.

As for effectiveness, spiritual claims aren't something a video can settle for you. You can keep notes on what you used, why you chose it, and how the practice felt, without turning every difference into a test you have to pass.

Plov-8c:

That distinction helps with books too. A source describing one custom doesn't necessarily mean everyone in that area practiced it the same way.

Reply to this answer
2j.daxqori

For the anxiety part, you could take a break from that content and return to the sources that actually interest you. You don't need to win an argument with every doubt. Sometimes noticing that comparison is making you feel bad is enough reason to step away.

Reply to this answer
_snoozy

One practical thing: familiar or locally gathered doesn't always mean safe. Identify plants carefully, and check the risks before burning them, putting them on skin, or using them around pets. You can value a plant symbolically without having to burn or ingest it.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.