One idea is that alleged Tall Greys descended from an ancient cephalopod lineage that moved onto land, rather than coming from space. Does the biology make that plausible, and what evidence would distinguish it from speculation?
Could Tall Greys have evolved from ancient cephalopods?
Answers
Cephalopods are an old group, but that alone doesn't establish that a humanoid branch evolved. The proposed transition would need a lot of intermediate steps: breathing air, supporting the body on land, reproducing there and reshaping the limbs. Those are hypotheses to investigate, not changes that follow automatically from the group's age.
There is also a more basic evidence gap. Descriptions of alleged Tall Greys don't establish that such organisms exist, let alone where they came from. A fossil sequence or independently verified biological material would be much more useful than a resemblance to an imagined ancestor.
Reply to this answer
The copper blood idea is at least a testable prediction. Many cephalopods use copper-containing hemocyanin to transport oxygen, whereas humans use iron-containing hemoglobin. If verified biological material from an unknown animal showed an oxygen carrier with a demonstrable relationship to cephalopod hemocyanin, that would be relevant evidence.
But copper by itself wouldn't prove cephalopod ancestry. You'd want to know what molecule it's in and compare its structure or genetic sequence with known organisms. Evolution could also change an oxygen carrier over a very long time, so assuming a descendant must retain the same system is a separate claim.
Reply to this answer
As a speculative evolution idea, sure, it's fun to think about. Ten ancestral arms becoming legs, arms and body-wall muscle is a proposed route, though, not evidence that it happened. A convincing case would need to explain the anatomy and show some trace of the intermediate forms.
Reply to this answer
I'd keep the illustrations separate from the argument. An image made from a written description can help show what the idea is supposed to look like, but it can't establish that the animal existed or that the anatomy would work.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
3q.dornvaki:
And the sample would need a well-documented origin and independent testing. Otherwise contamination or a misidentified ordinary sample could muddy the result.