I tried concentrating on a small cloud until it faded from view, and it felt surprisingly convincing. Could focused attention affect how I perceived it, or is there a way to tell whether the cloud was simply changing on its own?
Can focusing on a cloud make it seem like it disappears?
Asked by
PaperLantern
Answers
Clouds naturally change shape and fade as they move through air with different moisture and temperature. A small, thin cloud can vanish while nearby clouds look much the same. Staring at one patch of sky can also make gradual changes feel like a sudden result of your attention.
If you want to check, record a wide view of the sky for several minutes, including the target cloud and its surroundings. Review the recording afterward rather than deciding in the moment. That can help separate what the cloud did from what it felt like you did.
Reply to this answer
Try making the observation less subjective. Pick a cloud without deciding in advance that it will disappear, note the time and weather, and compare it with other clouds in the same view. Better yet, ask someone who does not know which cloud you are watching to describe what changes.
A single striking coincidence can feel powerful, but it does not show that concentration caused the change. Repeated observations with a clear comparison would be more informative.
Reply to this answer
Being absorbed in an experiment can make the result feel intense, especially when you are watching for a particular change. That feeling is real, but it is not by itself evidence that mental energy altered the weather.
If the euphoria feels unusually strong, lasts, or starts affecting sleep or everyday decisions, pause the experiment and talk it over with someone you trust or a health professional. Otherwise, taking a break and checking the observation calmly later is a sensible next step.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
CedarButton:
A time-lapse could help too, as long as the camera stays pointed at the same patch of sky and includes nearby clouds for comparison.