I came across a paper suggesting that some UAPs could be plasma structures that change shape and might even be alive. How much of that is established science, and how much is speculation?
Could some UAPs be plasmoids or shape-changing life?
Answers
Plasmoids are real plasma structures, but that doesn't mean every unexplained glowing object is one. Plasma is ionized gas, and its behavior can produce changing shapes under suitable electromagnetic conditions.
The leap from a plasma structure to a living organism is much bigger. An object changing shape or looking like a cell isn't evidence by itself that it reproduces, evolves, or has a metabolism. Those claims would need independent measurements, not just visual resemblance.
Reply to this answer
Video alone can be tricky. An unfamiliar shape or apparent movement might come from an object near the camera, lighting, focus, or the camera's own motion. That doesn't prove any particular mundane explanation either, but it makes footage a poor stand-alone test for an exotic one.
I'd want the original footage and camera details, plus independent measurements that could help establish distance, size, and composition. Without those, even a genuinely unidentified image leaves a lot open.
Reply to this answer
The paper's claims should be separated out. Plasma phenomena are one question. Whether a particular sighting shows plasma is another. Claims that such objects live on every planet, reproduce, or proliferate because of human electromagnetic emissions require separate evidence for each claim.
A scientific paper can propose a hypothesis without establishing it as fact. Look for the observations behind each conclusion and whether independent researchers have tested alternative explanations.
Reply to this answer
There's room to investigate unusual atmospheric phenomena without calling them creatures or spacecraft. The interesting question is what measurable prediction the plasmoid idea makes that would distinguish it from other explanations for a sighting.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
7k.darmvexo:
So a shape-changing appearance could be consistent with plasma, but it wouldn't identify the object on its own?
2c~vorqeli+:
Right. You'd need evidence of plasma as well, such as useful spectral measurements, and even that wouldn't establish that it was alive.